The song Only In America

Mann and Weil

An old blogger buddy included the song Only In America in his K-Chuck Radio post, Just wipe the vocals off, and we’ll take care of things.

One example of his: the backing tracks of California Dreamin’ by Barry McGuire and by The Mamas and The Papas are virtually identical. I had heard the McGuire version some years ago.

The Only In America story is somewhat more complicated. The great Brill Building songwriters Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil initially wrote the piece. As Songfacts noted:

“The song was written at a time before integration, and the lyrics were originally about racism. It had the following chorus:

Only in America, land of opportunity
Can they save a seat in the back of the bus just for me

Only in America, where they preach the Golden Rule
Will they start to march when my kids go to school”

To the best of my knowledge from the different tellings, this version was never recorded.

New lyrics

“The [new, additional] songwriters [producers Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller] changed [the lyrics] to be a satiric message of patriotism. The Drifters recorded the song with these new ‘patriotic’ lyrics but refused to release it because they did not believe that message.”

Only in America Can a guy from anywhere
Go to sleep a pauper and wake up a millionaire

Only in America Can a kid without a cent
Get a break and maybe grow up to be President

A 2008 article in the Long Beach Post offers a different explanation for why the Drifters didn’t release the tamer version.

“The song, with its gentle Latin rolling beat and percussion thump, could have been the next chart hit for the Drifters if Atlantic Records executive Jerry Wexler hadn’t pulled the recording. Wexler said that, in the light of race relations of that time, it would be unfeeling, unfair, and unfitting to have a black group release a song about America being the land of opportunity and suggest that an African-American could become its president.”

The song was recorded a few months later by Jay and the Americans, who Leiber and Stoller produced. It became a moderate hit, reaching #25 pop on the Billboard charts. I remember the Americans’ version then, and as a kid, I found it not credible.

In any case, The Drifters’ version appeared for the first time in the 1972 UK LP “Saturday Night At The Club.”  The cut was conducted by Garry Sherman and recorded on April 12, 1963. 

Lead singer

I’ve read in several sources that Rudy Lewis was the lead singer on The Drifters’ version. One of the YouTube videos of Only In America lists the group at the session as Billy Davis, Charlie Thomas, Eugene Pearson, Johnny Terry, and Lewis.

Marv Goldberg’s Later Drifters notes: “At their April 12 [1963] session, they recorded Only In America (led by Rudy), Rat Race (Rudy) [#71 pop], If You Don’t Come Back (Johnny Moore), and I’ll Take You Home (Johnny Moore).”

From a 2016 From The Vaults post: “Lewis is probably the most underrated of all the Drifters’ lead singers. He had the bad fortune to come in after Ben E. King redefined the group’s sound and never got the recognition that King did.” And King had had a series of solo hits.

Nevertheless, Lewis, who sang with the legendary gospel arranger Clara Ward,  was the primary lead from 1961 to 1963 and had hits such as Some Kind Of Wonderful (#6 RB, #32 pop in 1961), Up On The Roof (#4 RB, #5 pop in 1963) and On Broadway (#7 RB, #9 pop in 1963). He died in 1964, at least in part from drug use, an early member of the 27 Club.  He is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

Here’s Jay & the Americans with Charlie Thomas’ Drifters performing Only in America live, obviously many years later.

My Jimmy Carter confessional

James Earl Carter at 100

The 39th president turns 100 today. So it’s time for my Jimmy Carter confessional. I never voted for James Earl Carter when he ran for president, either in the primaries or in the general elections in 1976 and 1980.

In 1976, I believe I voted for progressive Fred Harris in the primary.

I was wary of Carter. As this 2023 NYT article discusses, he was a “white politician from the South who once supported segregationist policies [who] eventually won the enduring support of Black voters.”

During the campaign, he debated President Gerald Ford in three televised debates, the first since the 1960 Kennedy-Nixon debates. During the middle event on October 6, Ford declared,  “There is no Soviet domination of Eastern Europe, and there never will be under a Ford administration.” That hurt Jerry greatly.

But I was uncomfortable with Jimmy’s Playboy interview that autumn. As this 2023 Daily Kos piece noted, “The centerfold was not the topic of discussion [among the writer’s associates.]. It was the interview with Jimmy Carter. The ‘peanut farming hick’ and ‘goody two-shoes Sunday school teacher’ (their words, not mine) had actually admitted, in a national publication with a readership of millions, to having committed adultery in his heart. Many times in fact.” It may have made others take him less seriously, especially compared with the 45th president, who NEVER apologizes.

Ultimately, I was very disturbed by the weird machinations of the Carter people in New York, who kept Eugene McCarthy, the firebrand who ran against Lyndon Johnson in 1968, off the NYS primary ballot. He wouldn’t get the nomination; the primary challengers were Mo Udall, Henry Jackson, and Jerry Brown. Still, I was annoyed so much that in the general election, I voted for McCarthy as a write-in.

In office

Jimmy Carter’s Presidency is reflected by the National Archives’ description of something else that happened on this date.  “Opened on October 1, 1986, the Jimmy Carter Presidential Library in Atlanta holds 27 million pages of records, half a million photographs, and hundreds of hours of film, audio, and video from the Carter administration. Records cover the wide-ranging topics of the administration including the energy crisis, SALT II, Panama Canal Treaty, Camp David Summit and the Camp David Accords, Deng Xiaoping’s visit to Washington, establishment of the Department of Education and the Department of Energy, Iran Hostage Crisis, and more. “

Ah, Iran hostage. The daily count of 52 Americans held for 444 days. The failed rescue mission.

“During his term, Jimmy Carter took 12 international trips and visited 25 countries. He was the first president to visit Nigeria (and sub-Saharan Africa) and Guadeloupe.”

A recent Associated Press story suggested that Carter’s real problem was that “he faced two barriers: the congressional leaders did not view him as one of them, and the national media approached him with a regional bias against the South. Long after leaving office, he still bemoaned the political cartoon published around his inauguration that depicted his family approaching the White House with his mother, Miss Lillian, chewing on a hayseed.”

1980

When the 1980 Democratic presidential primaries came, I didn’t vote for Jimmy Carter. Nor did I choose Ted Kennedy because I was afraid he would be assassinated like his brothers. Also, in an interview with Roger Mudd in 1979, EMK could not articulate why he wanted to be president. I probably wrote in Jerry Brown.

I certainly wasn’t going to vote for Reagan in the general election. He was terrible, but how effective could he be? As it turns out, big tax cuts for the rich, gutting unions, and ignoring AIDS. So awful, much worse than I had imagined. I didn’t vote for Carter or third-party candidate John Anderson. Instead, I voted for environmentalist Barry Commoner, who wrote the 1971 book The Closing Circle, which I had read. It would not be the last time I voted for a minor-party candidate.

Best ex-President ever

After licking his wounds, “Mr. Carter has championed humanitarian causes and engaged in conflict mediation through the non-partisan and non-profit Carter Center [founded in 1982]. He found sustained success working on issues like global democracy, human rights advocacy, and the eradication of disease. In 2002, his efforts were recognized with the Nobel Peace Prize. He was only the third U.S. President to be awarded this prize” at the time.

The former President and his late wife, Rosalynn, were well-known Habitat for Humanity volunteers. He also regularly taught Sunday school at his church.

Jimmy has defied expectations in his hospice care in Plains, GA, which he entered in February 2023.  “Electing hospice care signals a person is nearing the end of life, where care focuses on comfort rather than continued treatment. One study found 93% of hospice patients pass away within six months.” He even attended the funeral of his wife, Rosalynn Carter, in November 2023.

Jimmy recovered in 2015 from a melanoma diagnosis that spread to his brain and liver.

Facts

The National Archives had some interesting facts, written a year ago and updated.

Jimmy Carter holds several interesting records as president. At 100, he is our longest-lived president… In 2012, he surpassed Herbert Hoover’s record for the longest-retired president. He and his wife Rosalynn had the longest presidential marriage at over 77 years.

Additionally, Carter holds many presidential firsts, including the first president born in a hospital. On October 1, 1924, he was born at the Wise Sanitarium, where his mother worked as a nurse.  He’s also the only president to graduate from the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis.

Jimmy Carter Stopped a Nuclear Reactor From Destroying Ottawa.

August rambling: the war on drugs

MAD magazine exhibit at Norman Rockwell Museum through October 27

Alfred E. Neuman and Norman Rockwell, 2002; Cover illustration for Mad Art: A Visual Celebration of MAD Magazine and the Idiots Who Create It (Watson Guptill, 2002) Oil on canvas
MAD and all related elements ™ & © E.C. Publications. Courtesy of DC

Nixon Started the War on Drugs. Privately, He Said Pot Was ‘Not Particularly Dangerous.’

California Sues ExxonMobil for Deceiving Public About Recycling Plastics

What’s 11,000 Times Dirtier Than a Toilet Seat?

Squirrel!

School Lunch: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver

Hugh Taft-Morales: Racism and the Weight of History | The New York Society for Ethical Culture

I Want to Free My Mother’s Killer From Death Row

No, the world doesn’t hate America: It’s still the world’s dominant cultural power, and that’s ok

Why You Should Never Make a Major Purchase on Your Phone

Are you in the American middle class? Find out with the income calculator

10 Worst Things About The djt Presidency | Robert Reich

15 Best FREE Printable Books for Early Reading

Longtime anchor Jeff Glor and three correspondents exit CBS News in a cost-cutting move (msn.com)

What Is Jeopardy!’s Future? One day, I got a furious email from one of the show’s stars. It only got weirder from there.

“Track Meet”-starring Heather Graham for MoveOn.org (2010)

Did Frank Sinatra Really Perform at My Grandma’s High School?

Writing about vaudeville

Sciolist: A person who pretends to be knowledgeable and well-informed.

My former blog, in Polish.

MADness

“What, Me Worry” is on view at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, through October 27, 2024. There is also an online symposium, The Usual Gang of Idiots and Other Suspects:
MAD Magazine and American Humor, on October 18 and 19.  MAD magazine on CBS Sunday Morning.

Dame Maggie Smith , grande dame of stage and screen, died at 89. I only saw her in the movies The Pride of Miss Jean Brodie (1969), Travels with My Aunt (1972), California Suite (1978), A Room With A View (1985), Sister Act 1 and 2 (1992, 1993), The First Wives’ Club (1996), seven Harry Potter films (2001-2011), Gosford Park (2001), The Best (and Second Best) Exotic Marigold Hotel (2011, 2015), Quartet (2012), Downton Abbey and A New Era (2019, 2022), and The Miracle Club (2023).

Now I Know: Like Two Ships Not-Quite-Passing In the Night and Why Isdied This Football Player Sitting in the Stands? and A Different Type of Mug Shot and The Problem With Food Allergies on Mars and A Slippery Way to Win a Football Game

MUSIC

Please note: all of the links in this and other posts worked when they were created. However, there’s a dispute between YouTube and SESAC (Society of European Stage Acts and Composers), a performance-rights organization similar to ASCAP and BMI. So, certain videos are blocked until the dispute is resolved. 

Rebecca Jade Rewind: Music Through the Years

Oldest Surfer on the Beach – Jimmy Buffett

Dolly Dagger – Jimi Hendrix

Elegy by Jonathan Leshnoff.

That’s The Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be  – Carly Simon

Coverville 1503: The Lynyrd Skynyrd Cover Story II and  1504: The Bruce Springsteen Cover Story IV

Polkamania! – Weird Al” Yankovic

Break It Up – Patti Smith

Romanian Rhapsody No. 1 by Georges Enescu

Crystal Beach – Kim Deal

Titanic suite

Mutations – Nilüfer Yanya

Suite from True Lies by Brad Fiedel

Panic In Detroit-David Bowie

The Abyss, suite from the film’s score, by Alan Silvestri.

Highwayman – The Highwaymen –

Pleasant Valley Sunday (2024 Re-Mix) -Monkees

Revolution – MonaLisa Twins

Anyone Who Had A Heart – Shelby Lynne

Hit Me With Your Rhythm – Ian Dury and The Blockheads

Circles – Of Monsters and Men

Missing You – John Waite

Please Please Please – Sabrina Carpenter

Klingon Style (Star Trek Parody of PSY’s Gangnam Style)

Hank Green explains The Forgotten Viral Video that Could Never be Made Today. Bree Sharp’s David Duchovny

More DNC music

Nebraska — Firework – Katy Perry

Nevada — Mr. Brightside – the Killers, a rock band from Las Vegas

New Hampshire — Don’t Stop Believin’ – Journey

New Jersey — Born in the U.S.A. by the New Jersey native son Bruce Springsteen. The song has often been misread by politicians; it is not an enthusiastic celebration of American birthright but instead a conflicted protest song, with criticisms about the Vietnam War.

New Mexico — Confident – Demi Lovato; the New Mexico singer has performed at the Democratic National Convention in the past.

New York — Empire State of Mind, a duet by two New York artists — Alicia Keys and Jay-Z — that became the anthem for the New York Yankees’ 2009 World Series run.

North Carolina — Raise Up – Petey Pablo, a hip-hop artist from North Carolina.

North Dakota — Girl on Fire – Alicia Keys.

Northern Mariana Islands — Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, a Motown staple by Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell.

Ohio — Green Light – John Legend, the Ohio native scheduled to play a concert in Chicago after the convention’s proceedings on Tuesday night.

Oklahoma — Ain’t Going Down (Till the Sun Comes Up) -Garth Brooks, the Tulsa, Okla., country legend.

Oregon — Float On – Modest Mouse, a band born in Washington but now based in Portland, Ore.

Pennsylvania — Motownphilly by the Philadelphia group Boyz II Men, and Black and Yellow by the Pittsburgh rapper Wiz Khalifa, a staple at Pittsburgh Steelers games.

Puerto Rico — Despacito– Luis Fonsi; one of the biggest singles ever by a Puerto Rican artist.

Rhode Island — Shake It Off – Taylor Swift, who owns a home in Watch Hill, R.I.

Sunday Stealing 200.04: Solitary

1, 1.414, 1.732, 2, 2.236…

This week’s Sunday Stealing is part of the 200 questions that Bev used the past three weeks. Here are 15 more from the same source, so I dubbed it 200.04. These were particularly intriguing, especially the question about solitary.

1. What do you want to be remembered for?

Let’s lean into the things I’m already known for: being my daughter’s father, being on Jeopardy, working at FantaCo comic book store, being a librarian for the New York Small Business Development Center, being smart,  being kind (well, usually)

2. If you were put in solitary confinement for a year, what would you do to stay sane?

I would think of all the British Beatles albums, singles, and a selected EP and try to figure out which tracks showed up on which Beatles US albums. Remembering the books of the Bible, which I used to know; I’m now weak on the minor prophets. Figuring out square roots. Trying to remember the musical artists I have in my collection and to think of as many songs by each of them as possible, starting with ABBA (Waterloo) would be the first off; Paula Abdul – what do I know of hers besides Straight Up? Remembering all the presidents of the United States and trying to remember their vice presidents and members of their cabinets.

If I had paper and pencil, I’d write my thoughts. A deck of cards could be entertaining. If I had books, I’d read them.

Where’s the video?

3. If you could have a video of any one event in your life, what event would you choose?

It was a performance of the Green Family Singers; my father Les, my sister Leslie, and I sang at an American Legion Hall near Binghamton in 1970. It was a particularly rowdy audience for us, but we went with it. Somebody asked me recently if I had a recording of my father singing, and I don’t, so that would be really cool.

4. What are the top 3 things you want to accomplish before you die?  Have you accomplished them?

One is to get our daughter through college; we’re in the process of that. One is to get further in genealogy. As I’ve mentioned before, there are two nuts to crack: my father’s mother’s father’s parents and the parents of my mother’s father’s mother, Margaret Collins. It would be satisfactory to get to that level in all branches. I’m talking to somebody from the Smithsonian this week about Samuel Walker, so I’m hopeful on that line. The third thing is something I’m working on, but I’m not willing to announce at this point. So, I have not accomplished any of them yet.

5. If you were forced to live one 10-minute block of your life again and again, what 10 minutes of your life would you choose.

I can think of a lot of things that I won’t share here. If pressed, I’d say the Double Jeopardy and Final Jeopardy rounds of the first show I was on.

6. Have you ever saved someone’s life?

Possibly.  Twice, I’ve yanked kids out of traffic. Once I performed the Heimlich.

Is this a surprise?

7. What are you addicted to?

Music. I have a very difficult time doing most things without music. When I’m cleaning, or when  I used to work at FantaCo or the NYS SBDC, I usually had music on, even if it’s with headphones. If I write, the music is on. Right now, it’s Traveling Wilburys Volume 3, which ends with a great song, The Wilbury Twist; it always makes me laugh.

8. What keeps you up at night?

This is a pretty regular occurrence: conversations I should have had, conversations I should not have had, things that could have said better, and things that I haven’t accomplished. A coterie of things.

9. What do you regret not doing?

Often, I play through scenarios whereby what would it have meant if I had done X versus Y? But the truth is that because I did Y, other things resulted. So I can’t dwell on it too much. I mean, I DO, but I shouldn’t because it’s not particularly useful.

10. What gives your life meaning?

The usual: friends, family, music, being useful

11. What are you most insecure about?

Body image

Busted?

12. What’s the most illegal thing you’ve done?

Back in the 1980s, a friend’s uncle was going through chemo, and he wanted to get some marijuana so that the uncle could stop feeling so nauseous. Somebody I used to work with almost certainly could get me some pot. So I bought it and sold it to my friend at cost. Now, marijuana is legal in many places, at least for medical purposes, but at the time, I could have been busted.

13. What’s the most surprising self-realization you’ve had?

I’m a bit sad that I haven’t traveled to many places: 32 U.S. states and four countries other than the United States. I was doing this project with my daughter, and I realized that it made me insist that she get her passport, which had expired at least seven years before, and I’m hoping that she travels abroad a lot more than I did

14. If you could make one rule that everyone had to follow, what would it be?

Try to make places safe for yourself and others. Two examples. When we were driving to church last Sunday, this woman, probably in her 20s, was on her phone, and she walked right in front of a car, surprised that it was there. She stopped before getting hit. Look around, people, and get out of your darn phone. Also, I was on a bus coming home from the drugstore. A  person came in with two heavy bags. When I wanted to get off the bus, I noticed they had placed the two heavy bags at the exit of the bus instead of on a seat – the bus wasn’t very crowded – so they created an obstruction for someone like me to get off the bus. I had to squeeze past the bags, which didn’t make me feel safe and secure.

15. In what situation or place would you feel most out of place? 

A room full of strangers with whom I am expected to interact.

Adult Contemporary #1 hits for 1984

The Honeydrippers

About half of the Adult Contemporary #1 hits for 1984 were very familiar to me. Incidentally, starting with the October 20 charts, Billboard changed the name to Hot Adult Contemporary.

Two songs appeared on the pop, AC, and Black Singles that year. Hello by Lionel Richie (2 weeks pop, 6 weeks AC,  3 weeks RB) did not connect with Arthur.

I Just Called To Say I Love You by Stevie Wonder (3 weeks each on all three charts) wasn’t my favorite Stevie song.

Additionally, Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper was #1 for 2 weeks pop and 3 weeks AC.

Stuck On You – Lionel Richie, 5 weeks at #1

Think Of Laura – Christopher Cross, 4 weeks at #1

Got A Hold On Me – Christine McVie, 4 weeks at #1

If Ever You’re In My Arms Again – Peabo Bryson, 4 weeks at #1

Penny Lover – Lionel Richie, 4 weeks at #1. Four of the last five songs, all except the McVie track, I’m not recalling. It’s not that I never heard them, but rather that they just didn’t stick to the brain.

Drive – The Cars, 3 weeks at #1. This track, conversely, I recall and have heard in the past few weeks.

Do What You Do – Jermaine Jackson, 3 weeks at #1. I remember this. What a strange video.

The Longest Time – Billy Joel, 2 weeks at #1. All three of the Joel songs are from the Innocent Man album, which I own. It was the follow-up to the more ambitious The Nylon Curtain album, so he went retro.

Leave A Tender Moment Alone – Billy Joel, 2 weeks at #1

What About Me – Kenny Rogers with Kim Carnes & James Ingram. I barely remember this.

Single week at #1 AC

An Innocent Man – Billy Joel

Believe In Me – Dan Fogelberg

Almost Paradise… Love Theme from Footloose – Mike Reno & Ann Wilson. This song is so generic that I barely remember it, even though I listened to the Footloose soundtrack earlier this year.

Sea Of Love – The Honeydrippers. I love this song and have The Honeydrippers’ EP on cassette, for some reason. The group consisted of Robert Plant and Jimmy Page from Led Zeppelin, Nile Rodgers from Chic, and Jeff Beck, like Page, a former Yardbirds guitarist.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial